Print Page | Close Window

Gilbreath myth continues

Printed From: MiddletownUSA.com
Category: Middletown Community
Forum Name: About Middletown
Forum Description: History and information about Middletown, Ohio
URL: http://www.middletownusa.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=5083
Printed Date: May 03 2024 at 7:19am


Topic: Gilbreath myth continues
Posted By: trimtab
Subject: Gilbreath myth continues
Date Posted: Feb 25 2013 at 7:12pm
Roger Miller's column in today's Middletown Journal (B6) perpetuates the myth of Victor Gilbreath and the character of a famous poem written 8 years after his death.
http://www.middle-america.com/wp/2012/09/14/victor-gilbreath/" rel="nofollow -
 the middle america blog post on this story

The confusion arises from a poem by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow called "Victor Galbraith". Mr. Miller's account follows the poem's storyline but the accepted history of the circumstances of Gilbreath's demise are detailed by the famous Ohio historian, Charles Galbreath in his multi-volume "History of Ohio".

http://www.middle-america.com/wp/victor-gilbreath/" rel="nofollow - History of Ohio Vol 1 pgs. 590-594

It's a much different story than the one presented in today's Journal.

Just like Mr. Gilbreath, some myths are hard to kill. This one just keeps rising up out of its coffin.



Replies:
Posted By: Paul Nagy
Date Posted: Feb 25 2013 at 8:04pm

Henry Wadsworth Longfellow published this poem he wrote in 1855.

Near the corner of Main Street and Manchester Avenue are two small monuments on a grass median between two parking lots. They’re visible from the street but are low to the ground and obscure; they face the space where  Elks Lodge #257 once stood at 103 North Main Street. This was the site of the home where Victor Galbraith was born.

There are several circumstances that are in question until this day.

 

“Victor Galbraith”

Under the walls of Monterey

At daybreak the bugles began to play,

      Victor Galbraith!

In the mist of the morning damp and gray,

These were the words they seemed to say:

      "Come forth to thy death,

      Victor Galbraith!"

 

Forth he came, with a martial tread;

Firm was his step, erect his head;

      Victor Galbraith,

He who so well the bugle played,

Could not mistake the words it said:

      "Come forth to thy death,

      Victor Galbraith!"

 

He looked at the earth, he looked at the sky,

He looked at the files of musketry,

      Victor Galbraith!

And he said, with a steady voice and eye,

"Take good aim; I am ready to die!"

      Thus challenges death

      Victor Galbraith.

 

Twelve fiery tongues flashed straight and red,

Six leaden balls on their errand sped;

      Victor Galbraith

Falls to the ground, but he is not dead;

His name was not stamped on those balls of lead,

      And they only scath

      Victor Galbraith.

 

Three balls are in his breast and brain,

But he rises out of the dust again,

      Victor Galbraith!

The water he drinks has a bloody stain;

"O kill me, and put me out of my pain!"

      In his agony prayeth

      Victor Galbraith.

 

Forth dart once more those tongues of flame,

And the bugler has died a death of shame,

      Victor Galbraith!

His soul has gone back to whence it came,

And no one answers to the name,

      When the Sergeant saith,

      "Victor Galbraith!"

 

Under the walls of Monterey

By night a bugle is heard to play,

      Victor Galbraith!

Through the mist of the valley damp and gray

The sentinels hear the sound, and say,

      "That is the wraith

      Of Victor Galbraith!"

 

I had the pleasure of reading this poem at a high school event years ago.  Paul Nagy


Posted By: trimtab
Date Posted: Sep 16 2013 at 1:22pm
Hats off to Roger Miller for finally killing the Victor Gilbreath myth in today's Middletown Journal:
"True identity of bugler revealed," 9/16/2013, B4

it's better late than never but the blog site that brought this new version of history to Roger's attention

http://www.middle-america.com/wp/2012/09/14/victor-gilbreath/" rel="nofollow - another memorial for Victor Gilbreath

goes on to discuss how newspapers and other media have a long history of propaganda for promoting and glamorizing war.

this is the appropriate subtext for Roger's retraction.

and is all the more relevant at a time when America's ruling class is insisting on war without the consent of the people.



Print Page | Close Window